Best Costco Tires (7 Tires To Keep An Eye Open For)

When the tread on your tires starts looking worn, every vehicle owner inwardly groans; tires are expensive to replace, especially when you have to do all four. Costco might charge an initial $60 or $120 membership fee.

But, the services its members receive access to, including its incredibly priced tires, are incomparable. Costco currently offers tires from four different manufacturers. Here are seven of the best tires to keep an eye out for!

Best Costco Tires In 2024

1. Michelin Primacy All Season

Starting strong, the Michelin Primacy All-Season is touted by the manufacturer as “the latest generation of fuel-efficient, all-season tires.”

Were you aware that your tires contributed to the car’s overall fuel efficiency?

That said, the main factor is called “rolling resistance,” and the better the quality of the tire, the better it rolls, basically, against the road, the less fuel the car expends.

Further, Michelin’s Primacy series tires have been designed and manufactured with materials to aid in the efficiency of the tires’ roll, ultimately saving you throughout the tire’s life.

Also, these all-season tires are designed for a quiet ride, with good traction in all types of weather. Overall, they are best suited for Fords, Toyotas, Nissans, Hyundais, and GMs.

Moreover, tire pricing differs based on your vehicle’s make and model, but a set of four Michelin Primacy Tour All-Seasons for a 2021 Honda CR-V costs $999.96 at Costco.

2. BF Goodrich Advantage Control

The BF Goodrich company has been in operation for over 150 years, and in the 21st century, the name has become synonymous with good grip.

That said, the Advantage Control series is designed to perform as well on wet roads as they do on dry, with a “network of curved sipes” that helps reduce hydroplaning.

Also, the tires offer improved handling and stabilization and upgraded braking performance.

However, the one con appears to be their performance on ice and snow; they simply do not enjoy the same traction in these conditions as they do on dry or rain-wet roads.

Still, World Tire Review gives the Advantage Controls a thumbs up, especially if you live somewhere that doesn’t see a lot of wintry weather conditions.

Also, they come in a wide variety of sizes to fit SUVs and sedans, and they are priced in the lower mid-range.

Outside of Costco, Advantage Controls cost about $160 per tire for a specific set. But, the same ones at Costco cost members more in the range of $98 per tire!

3. Bridgestone Turanza Quiettrack

If the roar of your tires on the highway is bothering you – or worse, when you’re simply pulling into any quiet parking lot – consider these Bridgestones from Costco.

That said, the Turanza Quiettracks fit many sedans and offer a quieter drive than regular tires.

Not only that, these all-seasons show surprisingly excellent performance and handling on all types of road conditions, including wet and snowy surfaces.

Moreover, they are designed with 3D full-depth sipes, in-groove ridges, and open shoulder slots, all of which grip roads or evacuate water from under the tires.

Lastly, the Bridgestone Turanzas can go for as little as $666 for the entire set of four at Costco.

4. Michelin CrossClimate 2

4. Michelin CrossClimate 2 Costco

These Michelin tires come highly recommended, especially if you drive in a climate that sees a lot of rain.

With that, the CrossClimate 2s are designed for excellent wet and dry traction and more immediate braking in both wet and dry conditions.

On the message boards, everyday customers highly recommend these tires, with some saying they perform better than the Bridgestone Turanzas.

Also, one Costco customer reported that they could get all four Michelin CrossClimate 2s, plus installation ($20 per tire) and tax for just $786.

Factoring in about $50 for tax would make the tires about $165 each. Additionally, keep in mind that comparable tires on Tire Rack go for $246 each!

5. Firestone Firehawk Indy 500

Do you like to zip around like you’re James Bond or in a Fast and Furious movie?

If that is the case, you need tires that can keep up and take the zig-zagging, weaving, and acceleration, all while maintaining the ever-so-important grip on the road.

Thankfully, the Firestone Firehawk Indy 500s are designed to do just that, as they are “inspired by [our] Firestone racing heritage.”

Also, these tires are meant for summer driving and will perform their most acrobatic feats on dry surfaces.

But, if you hit a patch of rain, Firestone’s “Proprietary Pulse Groove technology” ensures stable handling when the roads are wet.

Fortunately, sportscar owners don’t need to look any further than Costco’s selection of Firestone Firehawks!

6. Michelin Defender T + H

Longevity: every tire brand out there promises it, but who really delivers? Tires can be such an expensive investment, so you want a set that lasts.

Fortunately, the Michelin Defender T + H tires are an incredible all-around, all-season tire, with high ratings from Driving Press in dry, wet, and snowy conditions.

Additionally, they offer a comfortable, quiet ride, and, as Michelin states, the tread on these tires is long-lasting: “Michelin’s longest-lasting tire keeps you on the go longer.”

7. Bridgestone Dueler H/P Sport All Season

Ideal for light or sports trucks, SUVs, and crossovers, the Dueler H/P Sport All-Season from Bridgestone are designed to give drivers confidence on the road ahead.

Also, the tires are engineered to improve handling on both dry and wet road conditions and enhance overall fuel efficiency.

Thanks to the “high-silica tread compound,” which is molded over high-stiffness closed shoulders, the tires grip and evacuate water, so the rubber stays in touch with the ground.

To learn more about Costo’s tires, you can also read our posts on whether or not Costco installs tires, does Costco balances tires, and does Costco repairs & fix flat tires.


Along with Costco’s members-only pricing, in many cases, you can get awesome deals, like $150 off four tires with mounting by Costco.

Additionally, the company offers its generous five-year Road Hazard Warranty, plus care and maintenance for the life of the tires.

Photo of author

Cara Suppa

Cara Suppa has been freelance writing for over a decade and holds a BA in English and an MS in Integrated Marketing Communications. Outside of work, she is an avid cook, gardener, and discount shopper.

Leave a Comment