How Long Do Subway Cookies Last? + Other FAQs

As well as serving healthy submarine sandwiches and salads, Subway is known for its range of delicious cookies.

If you’re a fan of Subway cookies, you may be wondering how long they last after purchasing and what’s the best way to store them. After doing some digging, here is what I’ve learned!

How Long Do Subway Cookies Last?

Subway cookies generally last for around 36 hours after purchase. To prolong the life of your Subway cookies, they can be stored in airtight containers and placed in the fridge. Additionally, Subway cookies can also be frozen to be eaten at a later date.

For more information on how long Subway cookies last, including what’s the best way to store cookies, freeze cookies, and even make your own Subway cookies, keep reading!

Do Subway Cookies Expire?

As with all perishable foods, Subway cookies will eventually expire.

On average, Subway cookies can be eaten for up to 36 hours in their original packaging after purchase if stored correctly.

Also, Subway cookies in the store are only kept for one working day, after which employees throw them away.

However, if you wish to preserve your Subway cookies longer, you can store them in an airtight container or freeze them.

How Do I Store Subway Cookies?

To best store Subway cookies, it’s best to remove them from the packaging you purchased them in.

Ideally, Subway cookies should be stored with other similar cookies to not cross-contaminate.

For example, you should store Subway Chocolate Chip cookies separately from Triple Chocolate Chip cookies to preserve the life of the cookies.

Additionally, Subway cookies should be stored in an airtight container at room temperature, away from direct sunlight, which will help preserve the freshness, flavor, and texture of your Subway cookies.

Moreover, this storage method can keep your Subway cookies fresh for up to five days rather than just 36 hours.

Can I Freeze Subway Cookies?

Can I Freeze Subway Cookies?

Yes, another option for storing Subway cookies includes freezing them.

As with storing Subway cookies, you should not store different flavored Subway cookies together.

To freeze Subway cookies, place them in a freezer-safe Ziploc bag, and remove any additional air inside the bag.

Also, you can freeze Subway cookies in a freezer-safe container.

That said, you can stack your Subway cookies in the freezer to save space if necessary, as it will not impact your cookies’ shape or flavor.

If you store them correctly, Subway cookies can last for up to three months in the freezer.

If you wish to defrost your Subway cookies, remove them from the freezer and their containers and place them on a plate.

Then, leave your Subway cookies at room temperature to allow them to defrost, which may take several hours.

If you wish to quicken the defrosting process for your Subway cookies, you can microwave each cookie for around 30 seconds on full power.

How Do You Preserve Subway Cookies?

Another tip for preserving Subway cookies includes placing a piece of white bread within the container.

With that, the white bread helps absorb additional moisture within the container, which can help to keep your Subway cookies fresh.

Can I Heat Subway Cookies?

If you prefer your cookies warm, it’s certainly possible to heat your Subway cookies.

To do so, place your cookies on a microwave-safe plate with a paper towel covering the cookies.

Then, microwave your Subway cookies for 15 to 20 seconds, and they will be ready to eat!

What Does Subway Do With Old Cookies?

Most Subway stores will dispose of the unsold cookies at the end of the night due to their shelf life of one day.

However, other Subway stores will place the cookies in plastic wrap and put them in the plastic cooler.

Also, Subway will rotate its cookies to ensure they stay fresh for customers.

Moreover, Subway has reported giving employees unsold cookies that it can no longer sell. 

Does Subway Make Its Cookies?

No, Subway doesn’t make its cookies. Instead, Subway sources its cookies from business Otis Spunkmeyer, the sole supplier of cookie dough to Subway.

Can I Make My Own Subway Cookies?

As well as purchasing cookies from Subway, there are several recipes online to help you make your own Subway cookies, which can be stored and frozen.

For example, there is a recipe for Subway’s white chocolate macadamia cookies and Subway’s chocolate chip cookies.

To know more, you can also read our posts on whether or not Subway has soup, if Subway has a seafood sub, and how long are Subway sandwiches good for.

Photo of author

Marques Thomas

Marques Thomas graduated with a MBA in 2011. Since then, Marques has worked in the retail and consumer service industry as a manager, advisor, and marketer. Marques is also the head writer and founder of

Leave a Comment