Why Are Subway Cookies So Good? (+ Other Common FAQs)

Anyone who has ever bought and sampled one of the yummy cookies at Subway knows just how addicting they are. Many have tried to replicate the taste at home, but the original cookie cannot be matched.

In other words, Subway cookies are among the best dessert items in the fast-food world, but why is that? If you want to learn more about how and why Subway cookies are so good, among other things, read further!

Why Are Subway Cookies So Good?

Subway cookies are so good because they’re oven-baked daily, making them taste and smell fresh. Additionally, reviewers have commented that Subway cookies are not too crunchy or gooey, with a fantastic scent that heightens the flavor. Also, Subway offers an excellent selection to choose from at a reasonable price.

Now that we somewhat understand why Subway cookies are so good, what are some other aspects people like or dislike? Read on to learn more!

What Kind Of Cookies Does Subway Sell?

Subway offers a nice variety of cookies that have been a big hit with its customers for years.

Further, there are several yummy flavors to choose from, which include, but may not be limited to:

  • Double Chocolate Chip
  • Regular Chocolate Chip
  • Rainbow Gem
  • Raspberry Cheesecake
  • Oatmeal Raisin
  • White Chip Macadamia Nut
  • Sugar
  • Peanut Butter

On average, most cookies are available. However, some specialty or promotional cookies could be seasonal.

So, if you desire or are looking for a specific cookie, call your local Subway before heading to the store to ensure its availability.

What Are Limited-Time Cookies Available at Subway?

In recent years, Subway launched a campaign to try new cookie flavors that might appeal to old and new customers.

For example, among them were the super popular Reeses Pieces and Birthday Berry cookies.

Previously, other promotional cookies have included equally popular varieties of the fave dessert, especially apple pie cookies.

Made with granny smith and Fuji apples, these zesty cinnamon-spiced cookies were available only in the Fall.

Does Subway Bake Its Cookies Fresh?

Subway franchises guarantee that employees bake the beloved cookies fresh every day.

While they’re not made from scratch, the cookies come in a pre-made dough that employees bake every morning.

Furthermore, employees indicate that the cookies often sell out by the end of the day.

With that, if you desire to get your hands on your favorite fresh-baked Subway cookies, try to get to the store early.

What Are Subway Cookies Made With?

What Are Subway Cookies Made With?

As stated previously, all Subway cookies come in the form of dough that employees bake daily.

Also, each type of cookie has its unique recipe and ingredient lists; however, there are some ingredients they all share in common.

For example, these ingredients often include:

  • Wheat Flour
  • Soy Lecithin
  • Milk powder
  • Eggs
  • Butter
  • Various flavors and emulsifiers

Of course, differences depend on the cookie type. For instance, white chocolate chip cookies contain milk chocolate chips, while macadamia nut-infused treats contain white chips.

Although numerous recipes try to mimic these cookies, no one has mastered the yumminess of the originals!

How Much Do Subway Cookies Cost?

Subway cookies cost .59 cents per cookie (depending on where you are in the world), regardless of the flavor or type. However, specialty cookies may cost a bit more depending on location and season.

Also, you can buy Subway cookies by the dozen for $6.49. Still, Subway cautions that each cookie is 200-230 calories and may contain nuts.

Can You Buy Subway Cookies in Bulk?

Indeed, Subway offers the ability to buy cookies by the dozen for under $7 bucks. While some find that a little pricey, others think the fresh-baked cookies are well worth it.

Also, there doesn’t seem to be a limit on how many dozens you can buy. Even so, you may want to consider Subway’s catering for a more sizable order.

Does Subway Provide Cookie Platters as a Catering Option?

Alongside Subway’s famous sub sandwiches, you can order a cookie platter for your work or casual party event. Also, Subway offers drinks and sides in its low-cost catering packages.

That said, if you’re considering catering a rather large event, ensure your order gets completed on time by contacting Subway ASAP.

Additionally, you’ll want to call ahead to figure out the cost of the items you wish to include so that you can budget effectively.

How Do You Warm Up Subway Cookies?

Even if you freeze the Subway cookies, you can make them taste fresh with a few solid reheating tips.

First things first, you’ll want to store the cookies with a piece of bread so the cookie remains soft.

Additionally, if reheating in a microwave oven, wrap the cookie in a damp paper towel and heat it for 15 to 20 seconds.

On the other hand, if you reheat the cookies in a conventional oven, preheat it to 300 degrees and bake for six minutes.

To know more about Subway cookies, you can also see our posts on how long Subway cookies last, who makes Subway cookies, and Subway cookie flavors.

Photo of author

Marques Thomas

Marques Thomas graduated with a MBA in 2011. Since then, Marques has worked in the retail and consumer service industry as a manager, advisor, and marketer. Marques is also the head writer and founder of QuerySprout.com.

Leave a Comment